Call 250-819-0105 shuswaphay@gmail.com
Shuswap Hay SalesHay · Forage · Delivery
Home › Hay Quality

Hay Quality

A practical guide for farmers, horse owners, ranchers and livestock producers: what makes good hay, how to read a forage test, and how to take a sample you can trust.

Two loads of hay can look alike and feed very differently. Colour, smell and leafiness tell you something, but only a properly collected sample and a laboratory analysis tell you what the hay actually contains. That information helps buyers compare value, helps sellers describe their product honestly, and helps owners feed their animals well.

What affects hay quality?

  • Plant speciesLegumes such as alfalfa and clover are usually higher in protein and calcium than grasses such as timothy, orchardgrass and brome, which tend to carry more fibre. In mixed hay, the proportion of each matters.
  • VarietyVarieties within a species differ in leafiness, how quickly they mature, winter hardiness and disease resistance — all of which show up in the bale.
  • Harvest maturityUsually the biggest single factor. As plants head out or bloom, stems toughen, fibre rises, and protein and digestibility fall.
  • Cutting numberFirst, second and later cuttings can differ in leafiness, weed content and stem size. Weather and timing matter as much as the cutting number itself, so test rather than assume.
  • Leaf-to-stem ratioLeaves hold most of the protein and the easily digested nutrients. Leaves shattered off during raking or baling — especially from dry legumes — take quality with them.
  • Weather during curingRain on cut hay washes out soluble nutrients and slows drying. Long curing times and sun bleaching lower quality too.
  • Moisture contentHay baled too wet can heat, grow mould and, in the worst cases, catch fire. Hay baled too dry loses leaves. Safe moisture depends on bale size and density.
  • Storage conditionsHay kept covered, dry and off the ground holds its value. Bales stored outside lose quality in the weathered outer layer.
  • Mould and dustMould and dust affect palatability and breathing, and matter especially for horses. Check by sight and smell, and ask a lab about mould testing if in doubt.
  • Weeds & foreign materialSome weeds are toxic to livestock; others just lower intake. Twine, wire, plastic and debris are hazards, and animal carcasses baled in hay can carry serious disease risks.
  • Nutritional compositionProtein, fibre, sugars, starch and minerals can’t be judged reliably by colour or smell. A lab test is the only dependable way to know.
  • Animal-specific needsA milking cow, a pregnant beef cow, a growing horse and an easy-keeping pony need very different hay. “Good hay” depends on who is eating it.

Nutritional measurements on a forage report

Forage reports vary between laboratories, but most include the measurements below. The last column shows whether a value is measured by the lab or calculated from other results.

Common forage test measurements
MeasurementWhat it tells youHow it’s obtained
Dry Matter (DM)The share of the sample that is not water. Every other nutrient is diluted by moisture, so DM is the starting point for comparing feeds and for rationing.Lab measurement
Oven drying, or predicted by NIR.
Crude Protein (CP)An estimate of protein based on measured nitrogen. It shows how much protein is present, not how well the animal can use it — heat-damaged hay can report protein that is partly unavailable.Lab measurement
Nitrogen is measured, then multiplied by 6.25.
Acid Detergent Fibre (ADF)The least digestible part of the plant wall (mainly cellulose and lignin). Higher ADF generally means lower digestibility and less energy.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
Neutral Detergent Fibre (NDF)The total plant cell wall. NDF takes up room in the gut, so higher NDF generally means animals will eat less of the hay.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
Water-Soluble Carbohydrates (WSC)Sugars that dissolve in water, including simple sugars and fructans (common in cool-season grasses).Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
Ethanol-Soluble Carbohydrates (ESC)A narrower group within WSC, made up mainly of simple sugars and excluding most fructans.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
StarchA storage carbohydrate. Usually low in hay compared with grain, but worth knowing when total sugar and starch matter.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
Non-Structural Carbohydrates (NSC)A combined sugar-and-starch figure. Labs and advisers define it differently — often WSC plus starch, sometimes ESC plus starch — so check which one your report uses.Calculated estimate
Added up from other results.
Digestible Energy (DE)An estimate of the energy an animal can absorb from the feed, usually reported for horses in Mcal per kg or per lb.Calculated estimate
Prediction equations using fibre and other results.
Calcium (Ca)A major mineral for bones, muscles and milk. Legume hays are typically much higher in calcium than grass hays.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.
Phosphorus (P)A major mineral that works alongside calcium. The calcium-to-phosphorus ratio of the whole diet matters as much as either value alone.Lab measurement
Wet chemistry or NIR.

As-received values vs dry-matter values

Most reports show results in two (sometimes three) columns:

  • As received (also called “as fed” or “as is”) — the nutrient content of the hay including the water it contains. Use these figures when working out how much to feed by weight.
  • Dry matter (DM) basis — the nutrient content with all water mathematically removed. Use these figures to compare different hays fairly, because they aren’t distorted by moisture.
  • Some labs also show an air-dry or 90% DM column, which roughly represents typical dry hay.

Worked example. A hay tests 88% dry matter and 14% crude protein on a dry-matter basis. As received, it contains 14 × 0.88 ≈ 12.3% crude protein. If an animal is fed 10 kg of this hay as received, it gets 8.8 kg of dry matter and about 1.2 kg of crude protein.

Always check which column you are reading before comparing a test with a feeding recommendation or another hay.

Laboratory measurements vs calculated estimates

A good report separates the two clearly.

  • Measured values — dry matter, nitrogen (for crude protein), ADF, NDF, sugars, starch and minerals — come from analysing the sample, either by traditional wet chemistry or by near-infrared reflectance (NIR). NIR predicts results from calibrations built on wet chemistry; it is fast and reliable for common forages, but less so for unusual samples.
  • Calculated values — such as digestible energy, total digestible nutrients (TDN), net energy, relative feed value (RFV), relative forage quality (RFQ) and often NSC — come from equations applied to the measured results. They are useful guides, but they are estimates built for particular feeds and animals, not direct measurements.

If you’re unsure how a value was produced, ask the laboratory.

Principles for proper hay sampling

A laboratory analyses only a few grams of ground hay, yet that result is used to describe a lot that may weigh many tonnes. If the sample isn’t representative, even a perfect lab analysis will be misleading. Hand-grabbed samples tend to over-represent either leaves or stems, a few cores can’t capture bale-to-bale variation, and poorly stored samples can change before they reach the lab. The result can be hay that is mispriced or rations that don’t meet animals’ needs.

  1. Define a uniform lotA lot is hay from the same field and cutting, of similar type, baled within about 48 hours under similar conditions. Each lot gets its own sample and its own test — don’t mix lots.
  2. Choose the right timeSample close to when the hay will be sold or fed, so the result reflects what the buyer or animal will actually get.
  3. Use a sharp coring probeUse a hay probe with a sharp cutting tip, driven by a drill or brace. A dull probe pushes leaves aside and under-samples them. Grab samples pulled by hand are not reliable.
  4. Pick bales at randomWalk the whole stack and choose bales without regard to how they look. Picking the best-looking or worst-looking bales biases the result.
  5. Take at least 20 coresTake one core per bale from at least 20 bales and combine them into one sample. Take more for large lots or hay that looks variable.
  6. Sample in the right place, at the right depthOn square bales, core straight into the centre of the end (butt) of the bale, between the strings, about 30–45 cm (12–18 in) deep. On round bales, core from the rounded side toward the centre. Avoid the top and sides of square bales, which only represent a single flake, and never core the same spot twice.
  7. Collect about 200 g (about ½ lb)Too little hay won’t represent the lot; too much may be sub-sampled by the lab before grinding, which defeats careful sampling. Follow your lab’s instructions and ask that the whole sample be ground.
  8. Seal and protect the samplePut the combined cores in a sealed plastic bag — double-bagging helps — press out the air, label it, and keep it cool and out of the sun. A truck dashboard is the wrong place for it.
  9. Deliver it promptlyGet the sample to the lab quickly, and avoid letting it sit in transit over a weekend. If you want to compare two labs, have the sample ground first and split the ground material — never split un-ground hay.
  10. Choose a lab with proficiency credentialsLook for a laboratory that takes part in a recognized proficiency program, such as NFTA’s certification program, and ask which methods (wet chemistry or NIR) it uses.

National Forage Testing Association (NFTA)

The National Forage Testing Association was founded in 1984 through the combined efforts of the American Forage and Grassland Council, the National Hay Association and forage testing laboratories. Its purpose is to improve the accuracy of forage testing and to build confidence in feed-testing results among growers, buyers, sellers and nutritionists. Through its proficiency program, participating laboratories analyse check samples and must achieve results within an accepted range to be certified. NFTA also publishes educational material on sampling and interpreting forage tests.

Learn more at foragetesting.org. Credit: National Forage Testing Association.

Shuswap Hay Sales is not certified by, affiliated with, or endorsed by the National Forage Testing Association. NFTA resources are linked here for general education.

NFTA educational resources

The following publications are hosted by NFTA. The summaries are our own.

Interpreting Your Forage Test Report

Walks through the parts of a laboratory report: how the sample is identified, the difference between as-received and dry-matter columns, what protein, fibre and dry-matter results mean, how calculated energy values are derived, and how to use the report when comparing hay or balancing rations.

More Details — Interpreting Your Forage Test Report

Understanding Forage Quality

Explains why forage quality is ultimately measured by how animals perform, and how plant maturity, harvesting and storage, digestibility, nutrient composition and each animal’s requirements combine to determine it.

More Details — Understanding Forage Quality

Principles for Proper Hay Sampling

Covers the practical steps for collecting a representative hay sample — defining lots, choosing bales, probe technique, sample size and handling, and choosing a proficient laboratory.

More Details — Principles for Proper Hay Sampling

Hay Sampling Certification Exam

By Dan Putnam and Steve Orloff. An exam on correct hay-sampling practice, offered through the NFTA website. It is provided by NFTA — not by Shuswap Hay Sales.

Hay Sampling Certification Exam

NFTA contact information

For reference only. This is the National Forage Testing Association’s mailing address — not the address of Shuswap Hay Sales.

National Forage Testing Association
Brian Shreve, Data Manager
PO Box 1470
Stuart, FL 34995
United States
Email: nfta@foragetesting.org
Website: www.foragetesting.org
NFTA contact page

A note on using test results

A forage test describes the sample that was analysed. It doesn’t, on its own, make a hay suitable or unsuitable for a particular animal or health condition. For animals with special dietary needs, review results with your veterinarian or a qualified nutritionist.